Should Marlins make run at Samardzija?

LOS ANGELES — You don’t just replace Jose Fernandez. The 21-year-old is too talented, and possesses too many intangibles. His energy and competitiveness are contagious.

Every aspect of Fernandez will be missed now that he is on the disabled list with a right elbow sprain. Every indication is the young ace will be out for an extended period. Surgery remains a very real possibility.

Losing Fernandez, obviously, is a crushing blow that has rocked the Marlins’ foundation.

What the Marlins can do now that Fernandez is out is make every effort to remain in the National League East race. While, on paper, the Braves and Nationals have the makings to run away with the division, neither club has. And like Miami, both those clubs have flaws.

If the Marlins think they can still be a surprise club in 2014, they should give every consideration to making a blockbuster trade. Think big. And there is a big arm that could be had for a hefty price.

Jeff Samardzija of the Cubs is a target for a number of teams in contention. Perhaps the Marlins should join the list.

The Marlins have some attractive arms in their system that could be dangled. Save parting with Andrew Heaney, their No. 1 prospect, Miami would be wise to weigh what the Cubs would be asking.

Obviously, the Marlins don’t want to thin out their Minor League pitching, but consider this: They have the No. 2 pick in the June 5 First-Year Player Draft. They are leaning towards taking a pitcher.

The main reason the Marlins shouldn’t throw in the towel on 2014 is the fact that they are 20-19, and still two games out in the division.

Even without Fernandez, the Marlins have four strong starters. Nathan Eovaldi, Henderson Alvarez, Jacob Turner and Tom Koehler each have upside.

Heaney could be arriving in a matter of weeks. Anthony DeSclafani also may be arriving soon. Both are very good.

The Marlins feel they’ve put together a club that has the nucleus to make some noise in the division. Granted, they are still young. But if the team is serious about reaching the next level, what better sign to the clubhouse and a skeptical fan base than doing something big?

Samardzija is an ace. The 29-year-old also would be more than a rental. He’s affordable at $5.35 million, and he isn’t on the brink of becoming a free agent.

Yes, the Marlins could bring up Heaney and hope he lives up to expectations. The lefty is immensely talented. But it wouldn’t be fair to ask him to save the season.

Samardzija could save the season.

This is a sensitive time for the Marlins. If they let the season slip away now, what will that mean to the long-term futures of Giancarlo Stanton and Steve Cishek?

Stanton is playing at an MVP level. He is ready to win. He is focused on winning. Even during this four-game losing streak, he’s kept producing, as he takes a career-high 14-game hitting streak into Dodger Stadium on Tuesday night.

Cishek has been one of the most dependable closers in the game.

Both of them have two more arbitration years left. But if the plan is to wait til next year, how much sense does it make to waste their high-end seasons?

Then you have a veteran like Jarrod Saltalamacchia, who is signed for three years to provide leadership. Saltalamacchia is entering his prime. He isn’t here to spend two years to develop the young talent.

The front office makes it clear they are looking to get through Wednesday, and find someone who can start in place of Fernandez in the series finale with the Dodgaers. After that, all options are on the table.

Will exploring ways to acquire Samardzija be one of them?

Joe Frisaro


It’s crazy. I like it! Samardzija would flourish with the Marlins. He’ll be here for a while. Once Jose comes back and Heaney is in the Majors, we could be looking at a rotation with Fernandez as the ace, and Samardzija and Heaney as second and potentially third aces. Then there’s Eovaldi and Alvarez rounding out the rotation, or even other of the Marlins pitching prospects. That would be a seriously strong rotation. Even for this season, Samardzija would do a lot to make up for the loss of Jose.

I would personally love to see it happen.

Great Idea. Jeff would be a Great pick-up.

Yes. Yes they should.
Nothing would prove to Stanton more that you care about winning and the future than going out and getting an ace to help. Even if it is not Jeff, there has to be someone with a big enough name to help.
Would a package of minor league arms do it? Like Nicolino, Hand, Caminero, and someone of DeSclafani (even though he is being called up) Flynn or Conley? They are pretty thin pitching wise, and probably want cost controlled arms. I would love to throw Turner in there, but he looks like a crucial piece to this season now.
Could they swing a TRUE blockbuster deal and get another arm or player as well? All i know of the Cubs is they are STACKED with minor league position player talent. They are rebuilding, and if we give them several weapons that they can afford for 4+ years, would they say no?

Pingback: NL Notes: Roark, Weeks, Gregorius, Marlins, Mets, Cards – MLB Trade Rumors

the only problem here is the Cubs want to hold on to him and he wants to stay with the Cubs, as long as he gets paid. Inevitably, he may end up being traded, but the Cubs asking price has been extremely high, and I wouldnt be willing to pay it. It may have gotten even higher with the way he has pitched so far this year. To get a decent idea of what they would want, apparently they asked the Blue Jays for Aaron Sanchez, Marcus Stroman, and more. They wanted Bradley and skaggs from Arizona. There were reports of other packages as well…I just dont think its worth giving all of that up for 1 1/2 seasons of Samardzija

Pingback: NL Notes: Roark, Weeks, Gregorius, Marlins, Mets, Cards

Luda, the Cubs do not want to keep him. The Cubs beat reporter has even gone on to say that the talks they are having are just that, talks.. Nothing concerning contracts, nothing concerning long term future, notta. The Cubs want him gone because he will not fit in their long term plans. They are looking at more along the lines of competing in 3+ years while all along stock piling their farm system. Jeff plays more of 2-3 in a decent staff, not a #1 like everyone makes him out to be. The plus side is he has never been injured, but the minus side is he is having one great year which is going to raise his value.

Any chance the Marlins might consider David Price?

Pingback: As Rangers and Marlins Look to Overcome Pitching Injuries, Jeff Samardzija Chatter Ticks Up | Bleacher Nation | Unofficial Chicago Cubs News, Rumors, and Commentary

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: